--- title: CFPB Appeal | CFPB to defend constitutionality to full court description: The CFPB appealed the October ruling in which a 3 judge panel ruled in favor of PHH. CFPB to defend constitutionality to full court. --- **800-848-0143** Request a Demo [Contact Us](http://softprocorp.flywheelsites.com/contact-us/)[Blog](https://blog.softprocorp.com/?__hstc=190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514783189296.1514788403894.2&__hssc=190569908.1.1514788403894&__hsfp=2437171227)[Careers](http://softprocorp.flywheelsites.com/about/careers/) Search [MySoftPro Login](https://my.softprocorp.com/?__hstc=190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514783189296.1514788403894.2&__hssc=190569908.1.1514788403894&__hsfp=2437171227) SEARCH BLOGS SEARCH ALL [![softpro logoMain](https://blog.softprocorp.com/hubfs/softpro-logo.svg)](https://softprocorp.com/) - [Products](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/) - [Standard](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-standard/) - [Select](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-select/) - [Hosted](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-hosted-software/) - [SoftPro 360 Integrations](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-360-data-integration/) - [ClosingsLIVE](https://www.softprocorp.com/closingslive) - [SoftPro Sign](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-sign/) - [SoftPro Banking](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-banking/) - [Eclosings](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/eclosings/) - [Product Quiz](https://www.softprocorp.com/product-quiz/) - [Services](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/) - [Maintenance](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/software-maintenance/) - [SoftPro Protect](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-protect/) - [SoftPro Consulting](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/softpro-consulting/) - [Reconciliation Reports & Services](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/reconciliation-services/) - [Development](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/custom-development/) - [Reports & Docs](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/custom-reports-and-docs/) - [Regulatory & Compliance](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/regulatory-and-compliance/) - [Training](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/) - [Web-Based](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/web-based-training/) - [Onsite](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/onsite-training/) - [Training Seminars](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/training-seminars/) - [Free Trainings](https://blog.softprocorp.com/webinars) - [Saved You a Seat](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/saved-you-a-seat/) - [Support](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-support/) - [Underwriter Documents & Downloads](https://www.softprocorp.com/resources/underwriting-documents/) - [Remote Support](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-online-support/) - [About](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Contact Us](https://www.softprocorp.com/contact-us/) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/) - [Leadership](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/management-team/) - [Corporate Citizenship & Social Responsibility](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/corporate-citizenship/) - [Careers](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/careers/) - [History](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/history/) - [Blog](https://blog.softprocorp.com/?__hstc=190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514788403894.1514795107582.3&__hssc=190569908.3.1514795107582&__hsfp=2437171227) - [Testimonials](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/case-studies-testimonials/) [![softpro logoMain](https://blog.softprocorp.com/hubfs/softpro-logo.svg)](https://softprocorp.com/) **800-848-0143** Request a Demo Search SEARCH BLOGS SEARCH ALL Search - [Products](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/) - [Standard](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-standard/) - [Select](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-select/) - [Hosted](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-hosted-software/) - [SoftPro 360 Integrations](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-360-data-integration/) - [ClosingsLIVE](https://www.softprocorp.com/closingslive) - [SoftPro Sign](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-sign/) - [SoftPro Banking](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-banking/) - [Eclosings](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/eclosings/) - [Services](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/) - [Maintenance](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/software-maintenance/) - [SoftPro Protect](https://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/softpro-protect/) - [SoftPro Consulting](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/softpro-consulting/) - [Reconciliation Reports & Services](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/reconciliation-services/) - [Development](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/custom-development/) - [Reports & Docs](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/custom-reports-and-docs/) - [Regulatory & Compliance](https://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/regulatory-and-compliance/) - [Training](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/) - [Web-Based](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/web-based-training/) - [Onsite](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/onsite-training/) - [Training Seminars](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/training-seminars/) - [Free Trainings](https://blog.softprocorp.com/webinars) - [Saved You a Seat](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/saved-you-a-seat/) - [Support](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-support/) - [Underwriter Documents & Downloads](https://www.softprocorp.com/resources/underwriting-documents/) - [Remote Support](https://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-online-support/) - [About](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/#) - [Contact Us](https://www.softprocorp.com/contact-us/) - [Overview](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/) - [Leadership](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/management-team/) - [Corporate Citizenship & Social Responsibility](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/corporate-citizenship/) - [Careers](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/careers/) - [History](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/history/) - [Blog](https://blog.softprocorp.com/?__hstc=190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514788403894.1514795107582.3&__hssc=190569908.3.1514795107582&__hsfp=2437171227) - [Testimonials](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/case-studies-testimonials/) - [Contact Us](https://www.softprocorp.com/contact-us/) - [Blog](https://blog.softprocorp.com/) - [Careers](https://www.softprocorp.com/about/careers/) - [MySoftPro Login](https://my.softprocorp.com/Login?ReturnUrl=%2F%3F__hstc%3D190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514864755853.1514869798011.8%26__hssc%3D190569908.1.1514869798011%26__hsfp%3D2437171227&__hstc=190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514864755853.1514869798011.8&__hssc=190569908.1.1514869798011&__hsfp=2437171227) [![softpro](https://blog.softprocorp.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Softprocorp%20Jan2018%20January2018%20Theme/images/logoMain.png?width=186&height=72&name=logoMain.png "logoMain.png")](http://softprocorp.flywheelsites.com/) ##### Request A Demo × Close ##### Contact Sales × Close # SoftPro Blog [Back to Blog](https://blog.softprocorp.com/) 2/28/17, 9:57 AM # CFPB Appeal | CFPB to defend constitutionality to full court Posted by [SoftPro](https://blog.softprocorp.com/author/leslie.wyattsoftprocorp.com) on 2/28/17, 9:57 AM - [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share) The CFPB appealed the October ruling in which a 3 judge panel ruled in favor of PHH.  The CFPB asked the court to rehear the case en banc, meaning the entire court would hear the case, rather than the three judges who initially presided over the case . On February 16th the full court of appeals granted that request.  The CFPB will argue its constitutionality before the full court on May 24th. 2017.  By ruling in favor to rehear the case en banc, the ruling from October that declared the CFPB’s leadership structure unconstitutional is vacated. To read more click the following link: [CFPB Appeal](https://www.cfpbmonitor.com/2017/02/16/d-c-circuit-grants-cfpbs-petition-for-rehearing-en-banc-in-phh-case/)   Topics: [Regulatory and Compliance](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/regulatory-and-compliance) #### Stay up-to-date on the information about industry regulatory requirements, events, customer successes, company updates, and more! ### Subscribe to Email Updates ### Recent Posts [see all](https://blog.softprocorp.com/)   ### Posts by Topic - [Regulatory and Compliance (243)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/regulatory-and-compliance) - [Integrations (82)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/integrations) - [Saved You a Seat Webinars (74)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/saved-you-a-seat-webinars) - [Guides & E-books (67)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/guides-e-books) - [Testimonials & Case Studies (66)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/testimonials-case-studies) - [Best Practices (61)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/best-practices) - [Webinars (61)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/webinars) - [Company News (55)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/company-news) - [Events (40)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/events) - [Technology (21)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/technology) - [Reconciliation (16)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/reconciliation) - [1099 (11)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/1099) - [FinCEN (9)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/fincen) - [SoftPro Select (7)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/softpro-select) - [ClosingsLIVE (5)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/closingslive) - [Commercial (1)](https://blog.softprocorp.com/topic/commercial) see all ## Ready to streamline your closing, title and escrow process? Contact Sales or call us at 800.848.0143 ![softpro logoMain](https://blog.softprocorp.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Softprocorp%20Jan2018%20January2018%20Theme/images/softpro%20logoMain.png?width=185&height=72&name=softpro%20logoMain.png) © 2026 ### Contact 800.848.0143 4800 Falls of Neuse Rd Suite 600 Raleigh, NC 27609 [Directions](http://softprocorp.flywheelsites.com/contact/) ### Email [General](mailto:connect@softprocorp.com) [Sales](mailto:sales@softprocorp.com) [Support](mailto:support@softprocorp.com) [Training](mailto:trainingadmin@softprocorp.com) [Consulting](mailto:consulting@softprocorp.com) ### Connect ### Sign up to stay in touch ### Quick Links - [Products](http://www.softprocorp.com/real-estate-software-solutions/) - [Software Services](http://www.softprocorp.com/software-services/) - [Training Solutions](http://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-training/) - [SoftPro Support](http://www.softprocorp.com/softpro-support/) - [Underwriter Documents & Downloads](http://www.softprocorp.com/resources/underwriting-documents/) - [About](http://www.softprocorp.com/about/) - [Careers](http://www.softprocorp.com/about/careers/) - [Blog](https://blog.softprocorp.com/?__hstc=190569908.2565e5b7b5a67b3a02e01a942807fecd.1514783189296.1514795107582.1514798595244.4&__hssc=190569908.10.1514798595244&__hsfp=2437171227) - [Privacy Notice](https://fnf.com/privacy-and-security/) - [Terms of Service](https://fnf.com/terms-of-use) - [Accessibility](http://www.softprocorp.com/accessibility/) - [California Privacy Policy](https://fnf.com/CaliforniaPrivacy)   [Website design & development](http://www.everest-agency.com) by [Everest Agency](http://www.everest-agency.com) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "SoftPro", "url" : "https://blog.softprocorp.com/author/leslie.wyattsoftprocorp.com" }, "dateModified" : "2018-12-07T21:02:23.300Z", "datePublished" : "2017-02-28T14:57:31.000Z", "headline" : "CFPB Appeal | CFPB to defend constitutionality to full court", "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://blog.softprocorp.com/2017/02/28/cfpb-to-defend-constitutionality-to-full-court", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://blog.softprocorp.com/hubfs/SoftPro_nosubtext-1.png" }, "name" : "SoftPro" } } ```