You’ve likely heard about seller impersonation fraud by now, but knowing it exists and understanding how it plays out are two different things. These schemes are becoming more sophisticated, so understanding the schematics is imperative for title professionals.
Why? Because the scale of the problem is staggering! The average title insurance fraud or forgery claim exceeds $143,000. Making matters worse, criminals are harnessing AI-driven identity forgery and easy digital access to public records, giving them the tools to bypass traditional safeguards.
In this blog, we’ll break down what seller impersonation fraud is, highlight the red flags agencies must watch for, outline best practices for prevention, and show how technology is equipping title agencies to stay one step ahead of fraudsters.
Use the links below to jump to a specific section of this blog:
Seller Impersonation Fraud: Best Practices for Title CompaniesYou probably already know this, but let’s do a quick primer. Seller impersonation fraud occurs when criminals pose as legitimate property owners to sell land or homes they don’t actually own. These schemes often involve forged identification and falsified documents, creating the illusion of a valid transaction.
The most common targets are:
Vacant or absentee-owned properties are particularly vulnerable because they’re often not monitored closely, giving fraudsters more time to complete a fraudulent sale before the true owner discovers the problem.
The damage is immediate and severe. Both the unsuspecting buyer (who may lose significant funds) and the rightful property owner (who could face costly legal battles to reclaim their title) become victims.
These schemes are often carefully planned. Criminals exploit publicly available land and tax records to harvest owner names, signatures, and property details. Forged IDs and falsified notarizations allow them to pass as the rightful property owner.
Here’s how these fraudsters operate:
The difficulty is that these criminals thrive at the same speed and convenience that consumers expect in a modern real estate transaction. The pressure to rush, whether from clients or your own internal deadlines, can make it tempting to skip steps. That’s why it’s imperative that “slowing down” be part of your team’s culture. Encouraging your staff to pause, verify, and validate protects both clients and settlement agents.
Of course, knowing exactly what to look for is the first step.
Red Flags of Seller Impersonation Fraud
Fraudsters may be clever, but they rarely operate without leaving clues. These red flags typically fall into two categories:
Property-Based Red Flags:
Seller-Based Red Flags:
Recognizing these warning signs early and talking to your customers so they can identify them before the file even gets to you gives you and your team the chance to once again pause, investigate, and stop fraud before it reaches the closing table.
While seller impersonation fraud is sophisticated, title agencies can significantly reduce risk by building layered defenses. Here’s a practical checklist to adopt:
Another step is to take advantage of the protections the American Land Title Association (ALTA) recently put in place. ALTA introduced new title insurance endorsements that provide post-policy coverage against forged deeds and mortgages, an added safeguard you can offer to clients who want peace of mind beyond closing. They’ve also updated the ALTA Best Practices framework, which emphasizes stronger identity verification, ongoing staff training, and careful oversight of notaries and signing agents. Incorporating these measures into your operations not only helps reduce risk but also shows your clients and real estate partners that you’re taking every available measure to protect them.
Though education and training are essential, technology also provides an added layer of defense that settlement agents can put to work immediately. SoftPro 360, our free vendor portal, offers an integration to help combat seller impersonation fraud. The ionFraud functionality that is part of Fidelity National Financial’s (FNF) agentTRAX gives title professionals an early warning system to help identify potential seller impersonation risks at the earliest stage of a transaction.
Key Features:
While the greatest value of ionFraud lies in surfacing critical red flags before fraud can progress, early detection also helps you avoid wasted time and resources.
Currently, the absentee owner search is only available through agentTRAX for FNF agents. However, SoftPro is exploring ways to offer comparable solutions for customers who are not affiliated with FNF. Other underwriters may provide similar tools and resources to fight fraud, so don’t hesitate to ask your other affiliate underwriters for more information.
Seller impersonation fraud is not a passing threat; it’s a crime that will continue to evolve as fraudsters adapt their methods. Staying ahead means staying aware of every stage of the transaction and never overlooking red flags. When you combine informed staff, sound procedures, and technology, you create the layered protection needed to stop fraud before it causes lasting damage. The result is stronger security for clients, communities, and the industry as a whole.
To learn more about the ionFraud integration in SoftPro 360, contact the SoftPro team today.
Would you like to download a PDF version of this blog?